As I received the set it looked in fairly used condition. It survived the trip half way around the world reasonably well. The 12BE6 had fallen out of its socket along with its shield and there were a couple of minor splits in the wooden cabinet which were easily glued together. It is an unusual looking set in that it is in a wooden cabinet but with a metal front panel plated to make it look like copper. To get the chassis out isn't as easy as it could be. The loop aerial has to be loosened and pushed towards the chassis, the knobs removed, and then the chassis unscrewed from underneath. It does not come out easily. This is also the first commercially made Fremodyne receiver I have seen to have the Hazeltine Fremodyne Circuit decal. My four others don't have it, although the Hazeltine patent is mentioned in small print.
This decal is under the set. Some might think it's an advertisement for cheap quality.
Extra loop aerial
One very strange thing was the "extra" loop aerial. Someone had paralleled the connections of another loop aerial to the existing one. The additional aerial was just left hanging there. What this was done for I can only guess. Perhaps the idea was to increase signal pickup. Problem is that the inductance is lessened and the RF tuning is basically thrown right out of alignment. Incidentally, the wires were twisted without soldering.
Under the chassis. A metal cover has to be removed first. The brown electrolytic condenser behind the speaker transformer was added sometime during the set's history. It proved to be unnecessary.
The internals were all typical...no surprises there. All components appeared to be original. Powering up the set brought in both AM and FM stations, though weakly. It seemed like audio gain was low. Thinking of the Howard 474, and the cathode poisoned 12AT7, I tried another and the FM sensitivity came up considerably. The line cord aerial actually seemed to work quite well and some lower power stations came in quite well. While I haven't measured it, the length of power lead could be a multiple of quarter wavelength in the VHF broadcast band. I did have to replace the mains lead as it had gone brittle in parts and the insulation wasn't the best. The new lead was cut to the same length. Unlike the Howard and Meck sets, the power line aerial is permanently connected in the Gilfillan. There is a short wire emerging from the rear which connects to the power line aerial via a 100pF condenser. What one is meant to connect to this single wire I'm not sure, and not being able to disconnect the line cord aerial wasn't a brilliant idea.
Cathode poisoned 12AT7...again.
So, yet again we can assume that most of the time this set was used on AM, with lack of plate current for the 12AT7 gradually killing it off. Again, I tried reactivating it in my AVO valve tester. Emission came up fairly rapidly, and placing it back in the radio seemed to indicate success with a stronger superregenerative hiss. However, it soon became obvious that sensitivity wasn't what it was with the known good 12AT7. It seems that every AM/FM Fremodyne set I get is going to need a new 12AT7...and I haven't even started work on my second Howard 474.
The speaker isn't brilliant and really relies on the cabinet baffling to work properly. The 21.75Mc/s IF coil is at the rear right corner.
Time to replace the condensers.
The new 12AT7 was working well, but audio was still weak, so time to go through the routine of condenser replacement and checking resistors. First thing I found was a 30uF electro connected to the cathode of the 35W4 which wasn't on the circuit, and didn't appear to be original the way it was soldered in, so I removed it. I changed all the paper condensers, even though none appeared to be leaky. While doing this, I discovered this set wasn't exactly the same as the circuit diagram. Some of the .01uF's were .05uF, and my set is using the three choke version of the Fremodyne circuit.
One thing I really liked with this set is the wires aren't twisted around the tags 27 times...and guess what all you other manufacturers who insisted on doing this...I have never ever seen a faulty joint where the wire is simply passed through the tag and soldered.
Powering up again, there was no extra hum, and the B+ voltage was correct so it would appear that 30uF condenser was not needed and the existing filters were ok. The audio was still weak however. Moving onto the Fremodyne section, at last I found something. The 10uF was o/c. Replacing it brought up the volume to pretty much what it should be.
From left to right, valves are: 12AT7, 12BE6, 12BA6, 12AT6, 35L6 and 35W4. The yellow wire is for an external FM aerial, and the green wire is for AM.
For the AM section, I discovered that the
loop aerial needs to be away from the chassis...the service manual quotes
1.25". Touching up the aerial trimmer helped also.
Checking the IF alignment indicated all was well there.
Poor AM performance.
Still not happy with the audio level so time to test all the valves. The 12AT6 and 12BA6 were noticeably weak according to the valve tester, and so was the 35L6, though only in plate current; it showed 20mA whereas it should be 40mA. The actual gain was still ok, however.
I didn't have a 12AT6 or 12BA6 to substitute, so I used a 12AV6 and 12AU6. The 12AV6 made no difference, so the original 12AT6 stayed. However, there was a useful improvement when I put the 12AU6 in so that's what I left in there. The difference between 12BA6 and 12AU6 is that the 12BA6 is remote cut off and therefore designed for AM receiver IF amplifiers with the gain controlled by grid voltage (e.g.. AGC or a cathode bias pot). The 12AU6 is sharp cut off, but in reality I've found it to work acceptably. The AM section in this set isn't exactly well endowed with gain so cut off won't be reached anyway, in my area where signals aren't very strong.
With the chassis back in the cabinet, the audio performance was much improved with acceptable volume on AM. Distortion was also much less. It would appear the speaker cone doesn't like to work without baffling.
Apart from the FM sensitivity, this radio is a poor performer compared to the Howard.
It really needs an external aerial for AM; the internal loop is insufficient at my distance from Sydney's MW transmitters (about 70 km away). Volume is all the way up, or not far from, for comfortable listening. I won't be using this set for MW DXing!
One annoying thing was the AM/FM rotary switch. When will manufacturers stop using round section shafts which allow the knob to slip? This radio was no exception, and it seemed that over the years the knob had needed to be tightened to the point of the knob breaking. I filed a flat into the shaft to reduce the problem and glued the knob back together, but eventually I can see the knob having to be replaced.
The heater circuit.
One thing I noticed when I first turned the set on was the dial lamp flickering at 50c/s. It was like a diode had been used as a heater dropper, but I quickly realised that there'd be no need with the valve heater voltages adding up to about 120V. I then noticed on the circuit that the dial lamp was fed off a tapping on the 35W4 heater, and was also in series with the AC supply to the 35W4 plate. I'd seen mention of this technique many times, but this was the first radio I'd acquired that used it. One of my Meck converters also has a 35W4 but there is no dial lamp, so never really thought about it before. It seems to be something of a compromise to power the dial lamp this way, and also explains why the lamp is dim when first turned on...most of the lamp current is from the B+ . It makes me wonder about the design of the 35W4's heater if it can put up with such a variation of current. The reason why the dial lamp can't just be put in series with the heaters is because of the switch on surge. When cold, the valve heaters have low resistance, thus forcing too much current through the dial lamp.
The European method is to have a thermistor to reduce the switch on surge. As the thermistor warms up due the heater current flowing through it, the resistance decreases to a low value. The other method is to put a resistor in parallel with the dial lamp to absorb most of the surge. However, it means the lamp is under run once the heaters have warmed up and is dim. The Howard 474 uses a thermistor as it has a selenium rectifier.
Gilfillan vs. Howard.
So how does this radio compare to the Howard 474? Well, it looks cheap. The cabinet must have been designed by Blandness Inc. because it's just plain veneered plywood built into a simple box shape. The Howard has an attractive bakelite cabinet with some detailed features. Also, the Howard has instructions on aerial connections, and the FM aerial is not permanently connected to the line aerial. The Gilfillan just has two wires hanging out of the bottom of the cabinet. The Howard uses a choke for B+ filtering while the Gilfillan uses a resistor. Not that this is a bad thing, but it does indicate cost cutting. The thermistor in the Howard's heater string is a sign of thoughtful design, and less concern with cost cutting.
Nevertheless, the Gilfillan is nice set to have, and any Fremodyne is welcome in my collection.
cablehack at yahoo dot com