|
Kurre Loudspeakers
They say you're supposed to tell the doctor everything so
I'll confess. I finished reviewing Dr Rod Crawford's Kurre
loudspeakers nearly six months ago, 'way back in 1997, but
they sound so delicious, I really haven't been able to
part with them, so I haven't yet sent them back. By the
time this review appears in print, the speakers will no
doubt be home with their designer in Canberra and your
reviewer will be wondering if any other small bookshelf
speaker will ever be able to measure up.
The Equipment
They say that beauty is only skin-deep, but that's not
true in the case of Legend's Kurre loudspeakers, because
what you'll find inside the cabinet is almost as beautiful
as what's outside.
Take, for example, the nicely-crafted Audax bass/midrange
driver (HM17OZO) located at the top of the cabinet. (Yes,
the top. The Kurre uses an inverted geometry, where the
tweeter is at the bottom of the cabinet, and the mid/woofer
is at the top.) This is a lovely little driver, with a large
magnet, a fully-cast frame, a rubber roll surround and
Audax's unique 'aerogel' cone. This aerogel material, for
which the company holds a number of patents, uses
carbon-fibres to impart stiffness to the cone, to prevent
break-up and ensure the cone acts like a piston over its
entire operating range. However, to prevent the resonances
that can occur in carbon-fibre reinforced designs, Audax
also incorporates a gel-like material, to provide a measure
of damping. Both are applied over a paper base. To ensure
the casting doesn't ring audibly, Legend has filled most of
the voids with a black, flexible, epoxy-like material. Since
heat dissipation in the frame helps keep the magnet cool,
the penalty for filling the voids in this way is presumably
a very slight reduction in power-handling capacity, but this
certainly wasn't apparent in the listening sessions, as you
will discover.
The Audax driver is recessed into the front baffle so the
frame sits flush with it, and is secured by four hex-headed
bolt our preferred method of driver attachment. The driver
is gasketed to prevent air leaks. The method used to secure
the gasket, and the washers underneath the bolts, is such
that I would not recommend users investigate the mounting
method for themselves, because proper replacement requires a
new gasket to be fitted - you cannot re-use the old one.
Despite the 170 mm claim for the bass driver diameter,
this is actually the spacing between the mounting holes in
the basket (a measurement method with which I personally
disagree, but one that is common in the driver manufacturing
industry). The actual diameter of the cone itself is 119 mm,
increasing to 140 mm if you elect to include the rubber
inverse-roll suspension (again, I don't believe in including
the roll surround in the measurement). This puts the
effective cone area at 111 cm2.
The tweeter is from Scanspeak, a lovely 28-mm fabric dome
unit (D2905) with a fabric roll surround. The tweeter is
recessed into the front baffle, and surrounded by stepped
layers of felt, which modify the dispersion characteristics
and also ensure there is no possibility of edge reflections.
If these drivers sound familiar, it's because they are.
They're the same drivers Legend Acoustics uses in the
much-larger Kantu design, which I reviewed last year
(Australian HI-FI Volume 28 Number 6.)
Inside the cabinet is a nicely-laid-out hardwired
nine-element crossover that uses three cross-mounted
air-cored coils, seven polypropylene capacitors and three
ceramic resistors in a fairly unusual configuration (two
additional resistors are added, one across the bass driver,
the other across the tweeter). Internal wiring is all
silver-plated van den Hul multi-strand cable that is
soldered at every joint: at the driver end to the driver
terminals and to the bi-wireable rear terminal block.
Internally, the cabinet shows signs of having been
extensively worked. The first stage of working involves the
positioning of wedgeshaped sections of rough-sawn softwood
on the bottom sides and top of the cabinet. Cabinet bracing
is provided in the form of a []-shaped brace in the centre
of the cabinet, which locks the cabinet walls tightly
together.
In the bottom half of the cabinet, behind the woofer the
internal damping arrangement comprises a small amount of
natural teased wool fibre that is sandwiched between two
squares of 'dimpled' acoustic foam. In the top half of the
cabinet, behind the tweeter, a large amount of teased wool
is inserted, but this time without the acoustic foam.
Like all Legends designs, the Kurre cabinet is available
in a range of Australian wood veneers, and the quality is
magnificent. The baffle is finished with a high-gloss,
textured painted surface. There isn't a grille, as such.
Instead, the grille is stretched around the front baffle,
and captured at the edge in a slot formed between the main
part of the cabinet and the front baffle. This is a very
clever design that cuts costs, eliminates the possibility of
grille rattle and diffraction and means you can very easily
make grille cloths in a range of decorator designs and
colours, should you wish. I have to admit that I had my
reservations about the deep blue-coloured cloth provided
with my review sample. It wasn't a colour I would have
chosen.
Aware that some audiophiles are not so much turned on by
appearance as by sound quality, Legend makes a vinyl-clad
version of the Kurre, which sells for $990. Given the high
quality and realistic appearance of today's vinyl finishes,
many audiophiles (and, no doubt, all 'greenies') will be
happy to purchase this version of the Kurre and pocket the
$200 they save by '50 doing. (Personally, I'd rather fork
out the extra for the real-wood finish.)
On the rear panel are two sets of inputs, with the (+)
and (-) terminals joined by extremely thick brass buss-bars.
These, of course, should be removed if you're biwiring and
left in place if you're not. You should make a special note,
however, that the terminals are arranged oddly, in that the
two (+) terminals are at the 'top' and the two (-) terminals
at the bottom. This is the complete opposite of most
four-terminal designs, which have the (+) and (-) terminals
running vertically As a result, I would recommend extreme
care when connecting your speaker cables to the Kurre. In
wiring could possibly result m damage to either the speakers
or to the amplifier.
Backgrounder
Since this is only the second review of a Legend product
Australian Hi-FI has published, and many readers may have
missed the first review, Legend Acoustics is a relatively
new addition to the compendium of Australian loudspeaker
manufacturers . Its owner and designer, however, is anything
but new to the loudspeaker design fraternity, having served
several years in the employ of Linn Products in Scotland,
where he was responsible for designing the Nexus, Helix,
Kaber and Keltic before returning to Australia to live.
(Well who'd want to live in Scotland?)
Setting Up
The architecture of the Audax drivers (they have an
exposed voice and a rubber phase plug) is such that I would
recommend using the Kurres only when their grilles are in
place, because the fine-weave fabric cloth will prevent dirt
and dust particles from contaminating the (very small) gap
between the voice-coil former and the magnet. It seems that
Dr Crawford agrees with me, because the Owner's Manual
provided with the speakers indicates that the frequency
balance of the Kurres has been optimised for operation with
the grilles in place.
The upside-down geometry means that it is absolutely
essential that the Kurres be operated on stands, a
bookshelf, or a wallmount bracket. Also, I'd recommend
against mounting them on any type of soft surface, because
of the possibility of high-frequency absorption of the
tweeter's output. Finally, if you are mounting them on a
bookshelf, make absolutely certain that the front edge of
the Kurre cabinet is level with the front edge of the
bookshelf.
Unlike many modern speakers, the Kurres are supplied as
'left' and 'right' speakers, so make certain you mount them
as such. The Owner's Manual has a very clear diagram, but in
essence, the array is such that when you're looking towards
the speakers, the tweeters should be inner-most. Having
already experienced the Legend Kantu speakers, which didn't
like to be toed-in to face the listener, I was not at all
surprised to find the Kurres are identical. Face them
directly up the room. Where you position them with regard to
walls depends on your domestic arrangements and, if we're to
believe what we read in Owner's manual, on your tastes in
music. The manual says "When sited with a wall close behind
them, the lower notes will be reinforced to extend the bass
performance for rock and contemporary music. When sited away
from walls, the soundstage (positioning of instruments) will
be optimised for jazz and classical music." I realise what
Legend is getting at, but I am not sure I agree with the way
it is expressed. This advice would seem to suggest that you
should not listen to a rock band performing in the concert
hall of the Sydney Opera House, or the Sydney Symphony
Orchestra performing at the Entertainment Centre. The nub of
the matter is that if you want a slightly bigger bass sound,
but are prepared to accept some bloom at lower frequencies,
by all means push the speakers back against the wall. If
you'd prefer a more delineated bass, and are happy to
sacrifice some bass output to get it, operate the speakers
away from the walls. In reality, I think that if you're
prepared to fiddle with speaker placement, listener position
and room furnishings, you'll be able to get the best of both
worlds.
After experimenting with three mounting systems
(bookshelves, wall-mounts, and stands) I have to admit that
in the end, my aural (but not visual) preference was for
quite tall stands that raised the tweeters up to seated ear
level. This meant the cabinets were actually quite high and
visually prominent in the room. An alternative would be to
use slightly lower stands and to tilt the speakers backwards
slightly, so the tweeters fired 'up' to the ear.
Wall-mounting however, also worked particularly well. In a
room with a standard-height ceiling (mine isn't) I think you
might get excellent results mounting the speaker near the
wall/ceiling intersection, so long as the cabinets could be
aimed downwards at the listening position but - and this is
important - if you do hang the speakers from the ceiling you
MUST turn them upside-down, so the tweeter is uppermost.
Listening Sessions
I think the bass alignment of the Kurre has been managed
so well that even though different listeners might have
slightly different preferences when it comes to positioning,
it really does come down to personal preference - nothing
more. The combination of a small sealed enclosure and a
small bass driver does not bode well for bass response, so I
was not exactly surprised that the Kurre's bass was neither
overly extended, nor overly 'big' at low frequencies'. That
said, I have to say that the bass is so well-balanced
against the midrange, and has such a gradual and graduated
roll-off with such low distortion, that it really does trick
the ear into imagining there is a lot more bass present than
there really is. This is a well-documented psychoacoustic
trick that's been known about for years, but is always
difficult to pull off, probably because designers make the
mistake of forgetting to concentrate on overall balance,
rather than just on extension. I think that in the Kurre,
Crawford has managed to pull it off. The result is that when
you're listening to bass lines, they almost seem to be an
octave lower than they really are. You get the aural
satisfaction of big bass without the big cabinet, the big
drivers and the big price tag. Of course in the end, like
the proverbial mirage, it is all an illusion, but it's so
musically satisfying that it seems churlish to say so. How
much bass are we talking about here? Well the Kurres are
essentially linear to the ear down to around 70-Hz, which in
musical terms is the two octaves below middle C, after which
they still bass, but at a much diminished level. So, as you
can see, you're not really missing too much, and certainly
you're getting no less bass than you would from any other
speaker with the same-sized bass driver and IB cabinet.
Tonally, the bass is very tight and immediate, without
the subtle looseness' of a bass reflex design, but the
penalty is that you also lose some of the bassy-ness' of the
sound: it's as if a little of the raw edge is attenuated.
This is not really apparent when listening to most
instruments, but is noticeable with percussion.
The midrange sound is well-balanced and smooth with a
pleasant warmth that is most noticeable when listening to
female voices. Interestingly (since the speakers share a
driver), I didn't think the sound was quite as rounded as
the Kantu - though I would be the first to admit that this
is a stretch of aural memory (albeit assisted by detailed
notes)! You'd really need an A-B to sort this out. I was
particularly taken with the way in which the Kurres handled
Canadian chanteuse Holly Cole - I don't think I have ever
heard Calling You sound more ethereal.
High frequencies were crisp and defined. I thought
perhaps a shade of 'air' was missing from the sound as
rendered, but the effect was very slight.
I was genuinely surprised by how dynamic the Kurre design
is, and how loud and efficient they sound, even in a
relatively large listening environment. Indeed in terms of
dynamics, I think the Kurre is the most dynamic small
speaker I have heard for some time. The relatively high
efficiency is also a plus, since it means that unlike most
small speakers, you won't need to invest in a powerful
amplifier.
Conclusion
Legend's Kurre is a serious little two-way that seems to
have been formed and voiced very much in a British mould. If
you're currently auditioning small or even large twoways
from any of the more famous British manufacturers, do not
make a final decision without auditioning the Kurre.
Greg Borrowman
AUSTRALIAN HIFI April 1988
|